The Gregory Jay Blog



Why we use the classical model of educaiton

Today I was asked the rather simple question of why I decided to use the classical educational philosophy when it came to home schooling my son. I answered the question but don't think I did it justice as I I don't think I was very convincing. The main reason for this is that although I have read and though a lot about it I have never actually produced an apologia for classical education neither spoken nor written. Seeing as I did so badly with the spoken defence I'll try the written here and see if I can do any better. At the very least my writing this will help me to get it straight in my head - I hope.

The main thrust of my reasoning was that classical literature (including Latin and Greek literature) was the most important factor in a child's education as it supplies the knowledge of the ideals of the civilisation of which they are a part. That the systems, organisations and institutions existing within said civilisation were created to uphold the ideals that are found within classic literature. I don't think I put it as succintly as that but that was what I was driving at. I use the classical education philosophy as the civilisation is its heart. The focus on history, ancient languages, literature and historical documents give rise to the a deep understanding of the civilisation that created them.

Classical Education and Civilisation

Without first mentioning the idea of civilisation, the argument above looses some of its force.

Kenneth Clark in his magnum opus 'Civilisation' said of it "What is civilisation? I don't know. I can't define it in abstract terms-yet. But I think I can recognise it when I see it."

Most people can relate to this sentiment. When I was young I would often find myself looking up at the vast church spire of St. Mary's just outside the family business in Stamford. So tall that if I looked up at it for more than a moment it would feel as if it was falling down on top of me. Though I didn't know it at the time I was recognising that which I couldn't define. The same could be said when I visited the Roman ruins at Vindolanda by Hadrian's Wall. Seeing the towns foundations still there after two thousand years and solid enough to walk on. The church, the bakery, the tabernae all still recognisible gave me a strong sense of history and of timeless civilisation.

For the most part people live squarly within their civilisation but we live within a huge contradiction in the west. On the one hand most people see the role of traditional Western culture diminishing and becoming less and less important and yet on the other it is literally all around us. Vanishing congregations accross the UK tell this story quite succintly. There is a church in every village and yet they are all empty. The Church I was married in in Baston doesn't open every Sunday anymore. In fact none of the churches in the area do, instead they take it in turn to open and put on a service. The congregations of three villages and a market town are now only enough for one church to open up.

The ancient Greek and Roman authors have been stripped from our curricula long ago. So much so that neither my parents nor my grandparents would have ever read Aristotle, Aristophones, Cicero or even Caesar. And most young adults in the UK wouldn't know Homer from Aesop.

You would think that although the Ancient authors and Christianity are being ignored that at least English literature must still have a a place in the minds and hearts of the population! I'm afraid that this has already slipped out of the popular conciousness and soon will go the way of the classical authors - the remit of specialists only. A GCSE in English Literature (a 2 year secondary school course) requires the study of one novel, one poem and one play! A poem, a play and a novel for two years!? After which a pupil can obtain a Genral Certificate of Secondary Education in English Literature. That's all it takes! And so of English literature most have the knowledge of one Shakespeare play (we did Twelfth Night,) a poem (We studied Philip Larkin) and one novel (For us it was Of Mice and Men, which is not even English literature, it's American!)

So What?

Why does it even matter that the people of the west have less and less understanding of traditional culture whether it's Classical authors, theology or English literature? Those things are all becoming less prominant and so less important in our societies, right? This is the common misconception, that somehow we can remove ourselves from our culture. It is not possible. We are what we are because our culture makes us what we are. We can learn our culture and actively be a part of it, we can disagree, refute it and fight against it or we can be unknowingly influenced by it but we can not choose to be outside of it. It is a part of us whether we like it or not.

When we accidentally push into a queue because we didn't see someone was in line and we realise and either apologise or just stand there feeling a little guilty, it is The Golden Rule working in our subconcious. I can tell you from 15 years in China that people here do not feel this.

When we watch a movie with a terrible but charming villian we are seeing Milton's Satan brought to life whether or not we know it.

When we complain about the government's spending we do so because of the expectations of governemnt that have been left to us by the classical authors. It is unescapable.

The people who think they oppose the traditional ideas of our culture or civilisation in almost all cases just prefer certain parts of Western Civilisation to other parts. We all do. Western Civilisation is far from perfect and so there is plenty to dislike and plenty that still needs to be improved. Very few people seriously disagree with the prominent political, economic, philisophical and ethical ideals of the west. Those of democracy, capitalism, freedom and the ethics of the Judeo-Christian religions. And none of those that do disagree are moving to Cuba, China or North Korea to escape such ideals, in fact most of the traffic seems to be coming the other way.

In fact, when people rage against traditional values in an attempt to make society more fair towards one minority group or another they use traditional values to do so. They do not use Chinese values or Native American values, no. They find the values they agree with within Western Culture and then remind the culture of these values. This happened with slavery. Slavery goes against the traditional values of the West. Man is created in the image of God and so to enslave man is to disrespect God. The West relies on the ideal of freedom which also cannot tolerate the idea of slavery. And so to destroy the idea of slavery we only had to look within our own culture. A similar argument can be made of the Transgender issue of today. Those seeking 'fairer' treatment for Trans people are using arguments which originate within our own culture, whether or not the are aware of this is the main issue.

If we are going to be influenced and compelled to use our traditional values and culture, it is better for us to understand it then to have it working on us without our knowledge.

This is what I meant to say...

Greg is a true Sinophile, fluent in Chinese and proficient in Tibetan he is a homeschooling Dad that also consults on the side. You'll often find him cigar in mouth, book in hand, waiting for someone to finish their work or for the coffee to brew.

17.04.2021  

Homeschool Redesign

Education

Since moving into our new house we never really settled on where we should be doing all of our homeschooling and sometimes we've lost momentum because of it. It's time I redesigned our homeschool!


14.04.2021  

Dharamsala

Album

Photos of Dharamsala


14.04.2021  

Tan Zhe Temple

Album

Photos of Tan Zhe Temple


11.04.2021  

Keto in China is easy!

Blog

I have been doing keto here in China for over 3 years now and I'm convinced it's easier here than anywhere else.


09.04.2021  

Tianjin TV Tower

Album

Photos of the Tianjin TV Tower


03.04.2021  

Why we use the Classical Model

Education

I was recently asked why ew use the classical model for homeschooling our son - this is what I meant to say.


03.04.2021  

Cigars - The Best Medicine

Blog

Having been a cigar smoker for well over a decade now, I see that it really is the solution for all of life's woes. Well maybe I wouldn't go quite that far but I always feel positive and energised after a good cigar, and maybe not for the reason you think.


19.03.2021  

New Tab Perfection

Linux

Having more control over what shows up when I open a new tab and the way it shows up is a part of my workflow that I had been overlooking. I've recently brought it in line with Unix philosophy of 'do one thing and do it well.'


17.02.2021  

Getting Things Done

Blog

A Rambly blog about how I use GTD and how my system has changed over the years.


17.02.2021  

Winter 2020

Album

Us over Christmas and winter 2020


04.02.2021  

The Crumpet Business

Blog

I managed to to start a crumpet business almost by accident, but it's going well and orders are still coming in daily!


03.01.2021  

Deciding on a New Year's Resolution

Blog

This year I had trouble trying do think of a New Year's resolution, not that I necessarliy need one but it is good to give the year some direction and to have something to focus on. I think I might have found something now though


06.12.2020  

My Password Manager

Linux

Long ago I gave up using someone else's password manager, hoping that they would keep my most sensitive data safe and protected and decided to create my own.


05.12.2020  

Why We Homeschool Part 1

Education

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


05.12.2020  

November 2020 Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


23.11.2020  

DWM is configured!

Linux

The process of setting up DWM has really brought me round to the 'suckless way' of patching rather than configuring, this is a post about me going through the process of setup, patching and configuration of my nice new window manager.


20.11.2020  

Building an History Curriculum

Education

I am currently in the throws of creating a new history curriculum, from scratch, for my homeschooler. In this post I talk about the reasons why I have decided to do such athing and the problems that I have already hit even though I haven't even started yet.


19.11.2020  

Productive Procrastination, Well Kinda...

Blog

After deciding to start updating my website a little more regularly I, instead of actually doing it, procrastinated for a week or so, productively I assure you!


18.11.2020  

Configuring DWM

Linux

After installing DWM, I am undecided as to whether to stick with it or not. I though i'd use this blog post as a way to think through the decision.


13.11.2020  

A new wm (Window Manager)

Linux

I'm a list maker! Almost every decision I make requires me to make a list. Here I make a list on what I don't like about i3, my current window manager and what I want out of a new one, hopefully I'll choose one after this!


05.12.2020  

The Train Tracks 2020 Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


05.12.2020  

Lockdown! 2020 Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


05.12.2020  

Back to Normal! Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


05.12.2020  

Summer 2020 Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.


05.12.2020  

October 2020 Album

Album

This post ended up longer than I had intended so I have split it up into two sections. This is the first. Why we homeschool: Problems with the education system.